Search “best macros for weight loss” and you’ll find 40/40/20, 40/30/30, 30/30/40 and a dozen more, each presented as the one that works. The research tells a calmer story: one macro matters a lot, the other two are mostly up to you.

The best macros for weight loss are the ones that fit inside a calorie deficit and that you can keep up: about 1.2 to 1.6 g of protein per kg of body weight (0.5 to 0.7 g per lb), fat at 20 to 35% of your calories, and carbs filling the rest. How you split carbs and fat makes very little difference to the weight you lose. Protein is the one worth getting right, because it keeps you fuller and protects your muscle.

Do macros matter for weight loss?

Calories decide how much weight you lose; macros decide how the diet feels and what kind of weight you lose. If you eat more than you burn, no ratio will make you lose weight, so start with your calorie deficit.

The best evidence comes from comparing whole diets. A 2014 meta-analysis in JAMA pooled 48 randomized trials of popular diets in adults with overweight or obesity:

Diet type Weight lost at 6 months Weight lost at 12 months
Low carbohydrate about 8.7 kg (19 lb) about 7.3 kg (16 lb)
Low fat about 8.0 kg (18 lb) about 7.3 kg (16 lb)

Differences between named diets were small, and the authors concluded that the best diet to recommend is the one a person will stick to. Behavioral support and exercise moved the results more than the macro mix.

How much protein should you eat to lose weight?

Aim for about 1.2 to 1.6 g of protein per kg of body weight a day, spread as roughly 25 to 30 g per meal. That is the range a 2015 review in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition linked to better appetite control, weight management and heart health markers.

Protein earns its place for two reasons:

  • It protects muscle. A meta-analysis of 24 trials (1,063 adults, about 12 weeks each) compared higher and standard protein diets with the same calories. The higher protein diets led to about 0.8 kg more weight loss and 0.9 kg more fat loss, and kept about 0.4 kg more lean mass.
  • It helps with hunger. In the same meta-analysis, 3 of 5 studies that measured it reported greater fullness with more protein.

If you train hard, you can go higher. In a 4 week trial, 40 young men ate about 40% below their needs and trained six days a week. Those eating 2.4 g of protein per kg gained 1.2 kg of lean mass and lost 4.8 kg of fat, while those on 1.2 g per kg gained 0.1 kg of lean mass and lost 3.5 kg of fat. That’s a demanding setup, not a requirement for everyone.

For a full breakdown by goal, see how much protein you need per day, and for easy ways to reach it, our list of high protein foods.

Low carb or low fat: which burns more fat?

Neither has a meaningful metabolic edge. A 2017 analysis of 32 tightly controlled feeding studies swapped carbs for fat at the same calories. The lower fat diets came out slightly ahead: about 26 kcal more burned per day and 16 g more body fat lost per day. Those are tiny amounts, far smaller than what you gain or lose by eating a little more or less.

So the claim that cutting carbs unlocks extra fat burning doesn’t hold up, and neither does the opposite. Choose based on what you like eating and what keeps you full:

  • Lower carb can suit you if bread and pasta make you hungry again quickly.
  • Lower fat can suit you if you like big portions, since carbs have 4 kcal per gram and fat has 9.

If you’re wondering why the scale jumps after a pasta night, or whether carbs at night are a problem, see do carbs make you gain weight?

How much fat should you eat when dieting?

Keep fat between 20 and 35% of your calories, the range EFSA sets for adults. Fat helps you absorb vitamins A, D, E and K, and very low fat meals tend to be less satisfying, which makes a diet harder to keep.

Fat is also where calories hide. At 9 kcal per gram, a 10 g drizzle of oil adds about 90 kcal, so the oil, butter, cheese and sauces you add often decide whether your fat target holds. Favor olive oil, nuts, seeds and oily fish over butter and fatty meat.

How many carbs should you eat to lose weight?

Carbs are the flexible macro: once protein and fat are set, they take the calories that are left. In the worked example below, that comes to about 42% of calories.

What matters more is which carbs. Vegetables, fruit, legumes and whole grains bring fiber, which adds volume and keeps you full for few calories. EFSA considers 25 g of fiber a day adequate for adults: our guide to how much fiber per day shows how to get there.

Here’s what common splits look like at 1,800 kcal a day. Percentages are carbs / fat / protein, and grams are rounded.

Split Carbs Fat Protein Notes
Balanced 50/30/20 225 g 60 g 90 g Classic, easy to follow
Higher protein 40/30/30 180 g 60 g 135 g Good for hunger and muscle
Lower fat 50/20/30 225 g 40 g 135 g Big portions, fat at the minimum
Lower carb 30/40/30 135 g 80 g 135 g Fat above the usual 35% range

All four can produce the same weight loss at the same calories. The higher protein versions have the edge for fullness and muscle. A split like 40/40/20 written as protein first (40% protein) goes beyond the 10 to 35% protein range US health authorities consider normal (see what macros are), and there’s no evidence you need that much.

How to calculate your macros for weight loss: a worked example

Percentages are easy to read but awkward to use. Grams, worked out in this order, are simpler. Here’s Sara: 75 kg (165 lb), lifts twice a week, target 1,700 kcal a day from the calorie calculator.

  1. Protein from body weight. 1.6 g × 75 kg = 120 g, which is 120 × 4 = 480 kcal.
  2. Fat as a share of calories. 30% of 1,700 = 510 kcal, and 510 ÷ 9 = 57 g (513 kcal).
  3. Carbs fill the rest. 1,700 − 480 − 513 = 707 kcal, and 707 ÷ 4 = 177 g.
Macro Grams Calories Share
Protein 120 g 480 kcal 28%
Fat 57 g 513 kcal 30%
Carbs 177 g 708 kcal 42%
Total 1,701 kcal 100%

Every figure sits inside the official ranges. The macro calculator does these steps for you, with balanced, higher protein, lower carb and lower fat styles. If you have a lot of weight to lose, it also caps protein as a share of calories, so the target stays realistic.

Common mistakes with macros when dieting

  • Chasing the ratio, ignoring the total. A perfect 40/30/30 at 2,800 kcal won’t lead to weight loss if you burn 2,300.
  • Cutting fat to almost nothing. Meals get less satisfying and harder to stick to. Stay at 20% of calories or more.
  • Low protein on a big deficit. That’s when you lose the most muscle.
  • Changing the plan every week. Give a split two to three weeks before judging it, and see why you might not be losing weight in a deficit if the scale stalls.
  • Guessing portions. Logging is what turns targets into results. BananaCal shows calories, protein, carbs and fat for every meal, whether you snap a photo, scan a barcode or describe it by voice.

Don’t go below about 1,200 kcal a day (women) or 1,500 kcal (men) without medical supervision. High protein diets are not suitable for everyone: if you have kidney disease, diabetes or a history of eating disorders, or you’re pregnant, talk to your doctor or a dietitian before changing your macros.

Quick checklist

  • Set your calories first: a moderate deficit you can keep.
  • Protein: 1.2 to 1.6 g per kg of body weight, about 25 to 30 g per meal.
  • Fat: 20 to 35% of calories, mostly from olive oil, nuts and fish.
  • Carbs: whatever is left, with at least 25 g of fiber.
  • Low carb or low fat: pick the one you enjoy, the results are similar.
  • Track for two to three weeks, then adjust calories before you adjust the ratio.

New to the basics? Start with what macros are.